The Crochet Knuckle Bump
I blame Ravelry. Since the day if first appeared, I have been obsessed with crocheting. Although I learned the craft when I was just a little girl, I had only what I would call a ‘fondness’ for crocheting, picking up my hooks every now and then making scarves, sweaters, afghans and the rest. And then came freakin’ Ravelry. Suddenly I couldn’t NOT have a crochet project going at all times.
In the midst of my Ravelry-induced crocheting frenzy, I noticed I was developing a bump on the inside of the first knuckle on the ring finger of my left hand. It started out as nothing but then grew. And grew. Soon I couldn’t get my rings on and if I bumped the bump a jolt of teeth-grinding pain would leave me breathless.
It was time to go to the doctor, who sent me to a hand surgeon. The surgeon felt up my bump and guessed it as a ganglion cyst, but he’d need to see some x-rays first to be sure. A few clicks later and the verdict was in. It was not, in fact, a ganglion cyst, but a calcium deposit. Ganglion cysts can come and go on their own, calcium deposits…not so much. ‘What caused it?’ I asked. ’Most likely an injury,’ he said. I thought for a moment and then asked, ‘How about stress?’ I followed up with an explanation and demo of how I hold my hooks and yarn. He nodded, ‘Could be.’ He then suggested surgery. Yeesh. ‘What if I just stop crocheting?’ I asked, ‘will it go away?’ He smiled, ‘Maybe, but I can guarantee this, either it’s going to get bigger, smaller or remain the same.’ Yeah, thanks doc, I thought as I left his office with his card in hand, the number to the surgical appointment line underlined.
When I returned home, I had decided to forego surgery for one month and stop crocheting cold turkey. Oh, my, that was difficult. I had just bought about 10 skeins of yummy yarn to make a jacket for myself. Christmas was just around the corner. Not to mention my mother’s birthday. No coat, no gifts, no nothin’.
While I nursed my bump, I pulled out my little-used knitting looms, which kept me company as I wallowed in my pity. During my crochet withdrawal, I knitted a couple of hats, a few pair of socks, some scarves and wrist warmers. While I lamented over the loss of my old craft, I noticed two things. First, loom knitting was as enjoyable as crocheting and second, the bump was getting smaller. After only a few weeks I could get my wedding rings on and without any pain. Of course this meant NO SURGERY, but it also meant no more crocheting for me.
When I told friends and family about the appearance and disappearance of my crochet bump, they all suggested that I keep crocheting but just not as much as I had been. I see their point, but I also don’t want to risk an unnecessary surgery. If giving up the hooks means not being flayed open like a fish, so be it. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have to check Ravelry for new loom knitting patterns.






Hi! sorry to hear you are on pain… visit “Crafting with carpal tunnel” group in Raverly, and check their first post. It helped me A LOT with my crochet/knitting pain!!! I’m not sure yours is the same, but it migh be useful…
Hi Shanti. Thanks for the info. Nope, not the same, I’m afraid. Good news has come out of the experience, however. I’m back to knitting! Oh what fun buying new needles and such. Like I need another excuse to buy crafting supplies.
And the best part is no knuckle pain!
Thats sad to hear! But you don’t have to give up the craft, you just need to change the way you hold the hook, I had to do that as well…but only because of pain. After awhile you’ll forget the way you use to crochet (:
Yani–I’ve been practicing holding the yarn differently (it’s not my hook-holding hand that gave me trouble) but it feels so incredibly awkward. The finger that had the bump seems to have a mind of its own. I was actually thinking of taping it to my middle finger to ‘teach it a lesson’.
Thank you Julie! Actually one of the worst things about the experience was not being able to wear my wedding rings. I actually went out and bought an inexpensive band to wear so I wouldn’t feel naked. Heh. I’m just glad I went with my gut and didn’t make the appointment for surgery. And as for the crocheting, I’m cool with saying goodbye to it. Besides, it’s a great excuse to try other yarnie crafts.
Don’t you hate it when you love something so much, yet it’s not 100% “healthy”? That’s quite an interesting story. Although I don’t crochet, I can feel your pain of something loved then lost. I hope in time you’ll be able to do a little. I guess that falls under the category of “all things in moderation.” Who made up these rules??
Hope you’re feeling much better.